Itemize Books Supposing Thirteenth Child (Frontier Magic #1)
| Original Title: | Thirteenth Child |
| ISBN: | 054503342X (ISBN13: 9780545033428) |
| Edition Language: | English |
| Series: | Frontier Magic #1 |
Patricia C. Wrede
Hardcover | Pages: 344 pages Rating: 3.8 | 10779 Users | 1337 Reviews
Present About Books Thirteenth Child (Frontier Magic #1)
| Title | : | Thirteenth Child (Frontier Magic #1) |
| Author | : | Patricia C. Wrede |
| Book Format | : | Hardcover |
| Book Edition | : | First Edition |
| Pages | : | Pages: 344 pages |
| Published | : | April 15th 2009 by Scholastic Press |
| Categories | : | Fantasy. Young Adult. Magic. Fiction. Historical. Historical Fiction |
Narrative Concering Books Thirteenth Child (Frontier Magic #1)
Eff was born a thirteenth child. Her twin brother, Lan, is the seventh son of a seventh son. This means he's supposed to possess amazing talent -- and she's supposed to bring only bad things to her family and her town. Undeterred, her family moves to the frontier, where her father will be a professor of magic at a school perilously close to the magical divide that separates settlers from the beasts of the wild.Rating About Books Thirteenth Child (Frontier Magic #1)
Ratings: 3.8 From 10779 Users | 1337 ReviewsCriticism About Books Thirteenth Child (Frontier Magic #1)
A book which brought a mix of good and bad reactions. Set in an alternate America called Columbia during the "Go West!" era, except this is a world of magic, and Columbia is a continent seething with magical wildlife, from woolly rhinoceroses to steam dragons. Add to this Eff, the thirteenth child of a Seventh Son, sister to a double-seventh who is expected to be as powerful and lucky as the thirteenth is said (by some) to be unlucky and prone to wickedness.The story followed the unluckyLike the sequel, ACROSS THE GREAT BARRIER, this book is set in a North America in which there are no Native Americans. While I accepted this as a fantasy universe, unrelated to ours (and I've read other books in which other races, including white, are omitted, and accepted them), and read it the book on its own merits, many people I respect deeply object to what they see as the deliberate erasure of the Native Americans. I tell you this so that you can make your own choice about whether you will
I think this sums it up.I'm not going to read the rest of the series.
I already knew about this book's seriously problematic issue of, you know, erasing the existence of Native Americans, so I would never have spent money for it. But I was given a free copy, and I was really curious about what the book was like, so I gave it a go.I actually thought that maybe the erasure of Indians thing wouldn't be that visible -- I was working on the assumption that the history I learned in school and a lot of the frontier books out there basically already do this, so probably
I really enjoyed the concept of this book, the idea of magic in the time of the American westward expansion, but ultimately the execution fell flat for me. A couple of things stuck out to me:* The complete lack of Native Americans. I can see this has generated some controversy. It stuck out like a sore thumb to me and left me constantly waiting to see when Wrede would introduce them. Alternate history is fine, but you have to go way, way back to find a plausible explanation for why no people
This was surprisingly good. Though I really shouldn't be surprised as everything I've read by Patricia Wrede has been excellent. This is the first book of a new series involving magic and magical creatures in the old US while mammoths and wholly rhinoceroses roamed. Eff Rothmer and her family moved to the Frontier when her uncle called the police on her to have her arrested (at 5 years old) because she was a potential danger to the family. As the thirteenth child, her life was viewed as cursed
Eff is a thirteenth child. Destined, according to common magic, to go bad. Her aunts, uncles, and cousins are all of the opinion she should never have been born. A problem they think still might be rectified . . .But Effs parents arent common. And when they make the extraordinary decision to leave the city and move the younger members of their family to the edge of the frontier, Eff has the chance to start over. To keep the secret. To learn aphrikan magic instead of avropan. To study with the
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.